What is the difference between return loss and VSWR?

May 04, 2022

For many engineers, there is no functional difference between return loss and VSWR (Voltage Standing Wave Ratio); after all, they are measurements of the same parameter. They both measure the amount of RF signal transmitted by a connector that is reflected back. 

So what separates the two? Return loss (See Figure 1) is a logarithmic measurement of RF signal that is more useful when displaying very small reflections. Generally, return loss is used when system designers are working with other elements that are also expressed in return loss.     

VSWR (See Figure 2) is a more common industry standard. Its intuitive measurement of RF signal is easily expressed visually. This is because VSWR is calculated through a ratio that determines the maximum to minimum voltage in a standing wave pattern and always has a positive correlation.

At SV Microwave, we test how much RF signal is reflected back in each interconnect. This is important to our customers because it is an instant measure of performance. A connector with a high return loss degrades signal integrity and can potentially damage various transmitting elements within a designed system. Generally, all SV connectors and cable assemblies have a VSWR of 1.2:1 or a return loss of -20dB.

As the signal frequency increases, achieving a low VSWR or Return Loss becomes more difficult.  This is because the signal wavelength decreases and is more likely to reflect off an imperfection in the coaxial transmission structure.  Imperfections are typically a result of machining and assembly tolerances in press fit parts.  Often SV’s products have a tiered VSWR specification where the VSWR requirement at low frequency (18 GHz or lower) is tighter than at higher frequencies (18 GHz+).

There are several ways that we ensure this standard. SV Microwave has invested in several different simulation software programs like HFSS and CST. Now, our electrical engineers can simulate and optimize the RF signal of a connector before production ever begins. With HFSS and CST, we bypass prototyping, decrease lead-time for custom designs, and increase the quality of our products, all before the metal is ever cut. 

Figure 1: Return Loss Plot

Return Loss Plot

Figure 2: VSWR Plot

VSWR Plot

Leave your comment

What is the difference between return loss and VSWR?

May 04, 2022

For many engineers, there is no functional difference between return loss and VSWR (Voltage Standing Wave Ratio); after all, they are measurements of the same parameter. They both measure the amount of RF signal transmitted by a connector that is reflected back. 

So what separates the two? Return loss (See Figure 1) is a logarithmic measurement of RF signal that is more useful when displaying very small reflections. Generally, return loss is used when system designers are working with other elements that are also expressed in return loss.     

VSWR (See Figure 2) is a more common industry standard. Its intuitive measurement of RF signal is easily expressed visually. This is because VSWR is calculated through a ratio that determines the maximum to minimum voltage in a standing wave pattern and always has a positive correlation.

At SV Microwave, we test how much RF signal is reflected back in each interconnect. This is important to our customers because it is an instant measure of performance. A connector with a high return loss degrades signal integrity and can potentially damage various transmitting elements within a designed system. Generally, all SV connectors and cable assemblies have a VSWR of 1.2:1 or a return loss of -20dB.

As the signal frequency increases, achieving a low VSWR or Return Loss becomes more difficult.  This is because the signal wavelength decreases and is more likely to reflect off an imperfection in the coaxial transmission structure.  Imperfections are typically a result of machining and assembly tolerances in press fit parts.  Often SV’s products have a tiered VSWR specification where the VSWR requirement at low frequency (18 GHz or lower) is tighter than at higher frequencies (18 GHz+).

There are several ways that we ensure this standard. SV Microwave has invested in several different simulation software programs like HFSS and CST. Now, our electrical engineers can simulate and optimize the RF signal of a connector before production ever begins. With HFSS and CST, we bypass prototyping, decrease lead-time for custom designs, and increase the quality of our products, all before the metal is ever cut. 

Figure 1: Return Loss Plot

Return Loss Plot

Figure 2: VSWR Plot

VSWR Plot

Leave your comment